← University
Neighbour Disputes: Easements, Encroachments, and Nuisance
0 of 4

A boundary survey commissioned in anticipation of refinancing revealed that the rear wall of a storage addition constructed 8 years earlier by the owner of a commercial property in a mixed-use district extended approximately 45 centimetres onto the adjacent lot. The adjacent lot, operated as a small-batch food production facility, had been under the same ownership for 12 years. The survey finding set in motion a dispute that would eventually encompass not only the encroachment itself but also a longstanding easement and complaints about operational disturbances that had simmered for months.

The 2 properties share a common boundary running roughly 30 metres along their rear lot lines. When the current owner of the storage facility purchased that property 6 years ago, title disclosed a registered easement granting the food production operator the right to use a 3-metre-wide strip along the eastern edge of the storage facility's lot for vehicular access to a rear loading area. The easement had been created by express grant 18 years earlier when both properties were under common ownership and had been exercised continuously since. The storage facility owner, unfamiliar with the easement's precise terms at the time of purchase, later installed bollards and a chain-link gate across the access strip, asserting that the food production operator's delivery trucks were damaging the surface and creating liability exposure.

The encroachment complicated matters further. The storage addition predated the current owner's acquisition, and no survey had been obtained at closing. The food production operator, upon learning of the survey results, demanded removal of the encroaching wall and restoration of the lot to its original condition. The storage facility owner responded that the structure had stood without objection for nearly a decade and that removal would be disproportionately costly.

Layered onto these disputes were the food production operator's grievances about exhaust fumes from diesel generators that the storage facility ran during frequent power interruptions, and the storage facility owner's complaints about early-morning delivery noise and odours from the food production process. Both operators had documented incidents over the preceding 14 months, exchanged increasingly sharp correspondence, and consulted legal counsel. Neither had yet commenced formal proceedings, but settlement discussions had stalled, and each party was weighing litigation against other resolution options. The properties remained in active commercial use throughout, with ongoing friction affecting daily operations on both sides of the boundary.

Easements: What They Are, How They Are Created, and How They Are Enforced

An easement is a legal right that allows one person to use another person's land for a specific purpose without owning that land. This concept, fundamental to property law across Canada, creates what lawyers call an interest in land that runs with the property itself rather than belonging to any particular owner. Understanding easements matters enormously for anyone who owns, operates, or manages real property because these rights can significantly affect how land may be used, what obligations attach to ownership, and what disputes might arise with neighbouring property owners.

The foundation of easement law in common law provinces rests on centuries of English property law principles that Canadian courts have adopted and refined. An easement requires four essential elements to exist validly. First, there must be a dominant tenement, which is the land that benefits from the easement. Second, there must be a servient tenement, which is the land that bears the burden of allowing the easement holder to exercise their rights. Third, the easement must accommodate the dominant tenement, meaning it must confer a practical benefit related to the use of that land rather than merely providing a personal advantage to the owner. Fourth, the dominant and servient tenements must be owned by different persons. These requirements distinguish easements from other property rights and ensure that easements serve legitimate purposes connected to land use rather than simply inconveniencing neighbours for arbitrary reasons.

That’s the free preview

You’ve reached the end of what’s open to read. The rest of this lesson is part of a $79 course — purchasing unlocks it, or sign in if you already have access.